Solid Democratic (8)
- Gillibrand (New York)
- Open Hawaii (Akaka)
- Sanders (Vermont)*
- Carper (Delaware)
- Cardin (Maryland)
- Klobuchar (Minnesota)
- Feinstein (California)
- Whitehouse (Rhode Island)
- Menendez (New Jersey)
- Manchin (West Virginia)
- Casey (Pennsylvania)
- Open New Mexico (Bingaman)
- Cantwell (Washington)
- Open Connecticut (Lieberman)
- Brown (Ohio)
- Bill Nelson (Florida)
- Stabenow (Michigan)
- Tester (Montana)
- McCaskill (Missouri)
- Open Wisconsin (Kohl)
- Open Virginia (Webb)
- Open North Dakota (Conrad)
- Ensign (Nevada)
- Brown (Massachusetts)
- Snowe (Maine)***
Leans Republican (2)
- Open Arizona (Kyl)
- Open Nebraska (Nelson)
- Lugar (Indiana)
- Open Texas (Bailey-Hutchison)
Safe Republican (4)
- Hatch (Utah)
- Barrasso (Wyoming)
- Wicker (Mississippi)
- Corker (Tennessee)
(Updates)
(2/29/2012) Moved ME-Sen from Likely R to Leans D based on Olympia Snowe's retirement, and NE-Sen from Safe R to Leans R with Bob Kerrey's run for Senate.
(12/22/2011) Updated WI-Sen (Likely D to Toss-up), ND-Sen (Leans R to Toss-up), and TN-Sen (Likely R to Safe R)
(3/6/2011) Created 2012 list.
***ME-Sen is ranked as Leans Independent, but toss-up because it's not clear whether King will caucus with anyone or not.